Hay for Metabolic Horses: Low Sugar Hay for IR, EMS, PPID and Laminitis-Prone Horses
The best hay for a metabolic horse is grass hay that has been lab-tested low in sugar and starch. Most vets and equine nutritionists aim for NSC (WSC + starch) under about 10–12% on a dry matter basis, and the ECIR Group uses ESC + starch under 10%. You can't see sugar in a bale, so the only way to know is a forage test of the exact lot you buy. HayNow sells two tested lots with their Dairy One reports posted, delivered in 18-bale pallets from Virginia to New Hampshire, including DC. Your vet should set the target for your horse.
This page is general feeding information, not veterinary advice. Hay does not treat or prevent insulin resistance, EMS, PPID (Cushing's) or laminitis. Work with your vet or an equine nutritionist on your horse's diet.
Our tested low sugar hay right now
| Hay and lot | NSC (WSC + starch) | ESC + starch | Starch | Crude protein | RFV |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Low Sugar 1st Cut NY Timothy-Orchard, lot 260910-01 | 11.4% | 4.7% | 0.2% | 8.9% | 81 |
| 2nd Cut Western Straight Orchard Grass, lot 261106-01 | 10.3% | 6.0% | 0.2% | 12.6% | 95 |
All values are dry matter, from Dairy One Forage Lab in Ithaca, NY (samples 31663310 and 31784540). Both lots are under 10% ESC + starch. Neither lot is under 10% NSC, so if your vet wants NSC under 10%, ask whether soaking fits your horse. Browse both in our low sugar hay collection.
What "metabolic horse" means when you're buying hay
Horse owners use "metabolic" for a group of horses that handle sugar and starch poorly. That usually means a horse your vet has diagnosed with insulin resistance (IR, also called insulin dysregulation), equine metabolic syndrome (EMS) or PPID (Cushing's disease), a horse that has foundered or had laminitis before, or an easy keeper that gains weight on air. For these horses, many vets work to keep non-structural carbohydrates (NSC) low across the whole diet.
Hay is most of what these horses eat, often 1.5–2% of body weight a day, so the sugar in the hay matters more than the sugar in a handful of treats. That is why owners search for low sugar hay, low NSC hay, low starch hay, or simply "safe hay" for a laminitic or IR horse. Those all point to the same thing: hay with a test that shows low sugar and starch.
NSC vs ESC + starch: which number to read
A forage test lists several carbohydrate numbers. Here is what they mean and which ones people use:
- WSC (water-soluble carbohydrates): simple sugars plus fructans. Fructans are the storage sugar cool-season grasses such as timothy and orchardgrass build up.
- ESC (ethanol-soluble carbohydrates): the simple sugars only, a smaller part of WSC.
- Starch: usually very low in grass hay. Both of our current lots test at 0.2%.
- NSC: WSC + starch. Many nutritionists use a target of about 10–12% or less for metabolic horses.
- ESC + starch: leaves fructans out. The ECIR Group, a large owner and vet community focused on IR and PPID horses, uses ESC + starch of 10% or less.
Read the dry matter (DM) column, not "as fed." Feeding guidelines are written on a dry matter basis, and as-fed numbers look lower only because they include the bale's moisture. If your vet names a number, ask which measure they mean. We post all of them so you don't have to guess. Our hay testing guide walks through the rest of a report.
Why hay type alone won't tell you the sugar
It's tempting to shop by species, but the sugar in hay depends more on how and when it was grown and cut:
- Cool-season grasses like timothy, orchardgrass and brome can run higher in sugar, mostly fructans, than warm-season grasses like teff or bermudagrass. Ryegrass can run very high. But plenty of timothy and orchard lots test low, and some teff tests higher than you'd expect.
- Time of cutting: grass builds sugar during sunny days, so hay cut in the morning often tests lower than the same field cut late in the afternoon. Cold nights followed by sunny days push sugar up.
- Maturity: more mature, stemmy hay tends to be lower in sugar and calories and takes longer to chew.
- Alfalfa is often lower in NSC than many grass hays, but it is higher in protein, calcium and calories, so many vets limit it for easy keepers. Ask before adding it.
Put together, two bales of the "same" hay can test far apart. Our two lots show it: the 2nd cut orchard grass tests a little lower in NSC (10.3%) than the 1st cut Timothy-Orchard (11.4%), while the 1st cut is lower on ESC + starch (4.7% vs 6.0%). The test, not the label, is what tells you.
1st cut or 2nd cut for a metabolic horse?
Sugar depends on the lot, not the cutting. The bigger difference between our two lots is calories and protein:
- Low Sugar 1st Cut Timothy-Orchard (8.9% protein, RFV 81) is coarser and lower in calories. It's a common pick for easy keepers and ponies that need to chew longer on less energy.
- 2nd Cut Western Orchard Grass (12.6% protein, RFV 95) is softer and leafier. Owners often choose it for older or picky horses, or metabolic horses that need help holding weight.
Both lots are still forage only. Hay rarely covers all of a horse's vitamin and mineral needs, so many nutritionists pair it with a ration balancer or a balanced mineral. Your vet can help match the hay to your horse's weight and condition.
Soaking hay to lower sugar
Soaking pulls water-soluble sugars out of hay. The ECIR Group cites an average drop of about 30% in sugar after 30 minutes in hot water or 60 minutes in cold water. Always dump the soak water, because the sugar is now in it, and feed soaked hay promptly so it doesn't spoil. Soaking also washes out some minerals, and it's messy in a New England or New Jersey winter when the water freezes.
Starting with tested low sugar hay doesn't replace your vet's plan, but it means you know where you're starting from. Some horses need numbers lower than any hay tests at, and soaking is how owners get there.
Feeding tips owners and vets often use
- Use a slow feeder or small-hole hay net so the horse eats over more hours.
- Limit or skip grazing on lush or frosted grass, which can be much higher in sugar than hay. Ask your vet about a grazing muzzle or dry lot.
- Change hay gradually over a week or so, and re-test when you switch lots.
- Weigh hay instead of counting flakes. Our compressed bales are about 43 lb each; see how much hay a horse needs.
Low sugar hay delivered from Virginia to New Hampshire
We sell tested low sugar hay online in 18-bale pallets of compressed bales, about 43 lb each. Order this week and we deliver next week. Our truck's forklift sets each shrink-wrapped pallet at ground level, so you don't stack a bale. Each pallet is tagged with its lot number, and every order is backed by our No-Mold Guarantee.
Delivery is free in Connecticut, New Jersey, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New York, Pennsylvania, Delaware, Maryland, Rhode Island, Vermont and Washington, DC. Virginia has a flat $39 stop charge. We don't deliver onto islands. See delivery details for Connecticut, New Jersey, Massachusetts and New Hampshire.
Hay for metabolic horses: FAQ
What is the best hay for a metabolic horse?
Grass hay that has been lab-tested low in sugar and starch, usually NSC under about 10–12% or ESC + starch under 10% on a dry matter basis. Species alone doesn't guarantee it, so ask for the test. Your vet should set the exact target.
What NSC level do vets use for insulin resistant horses?
Many nutritionists use NSC (WSC + starch) of 12% or less, and some prefer 10% or less. The ECIR Group uses ESC + starch of 10% or less. Our current lots test 11.4% and 10.3% NSC, and 4.7% and 6.0% ESC + starch (DM).
Is timothy hay good for laminitic horses?
It can be, if the lot tests low. Timothy is a cool-season grass that can store a lot of sugar, so some timothy is fine for laminitis-prone horses and some isn't. Our Low Sugar 1st Cut Timothy-Orchard lot 260910-01 tests at 11.4% NSC and 4.7% ESC + starch. Check with your vet.
Is orchard grass hay low in sugar?
Sometimes. Orchardgrass varies with weather and cutting time like other cool-season grasses. Our 2nd cut Western orchard grass lot 261106-01 tests at 10.3% NSC and 6.0% ESC + starch (DM).
What hay is best for a horse with Cushing's (PPID)?
Many PPID horses are also insulin resistant, so owners often use the same tested low sugar hay. Older PPID horses may also need softer, leafier hay or more protein. This is a decision for your vet; hay is not a treatment for PPID.
Does soaking hay remove sugar?
Yes, partly. A 30-minute soak in hot water or 60 minutes in cold water lowers sugar by about 30% on average, according to the ECIR Group. Throw out the soak water and feed the hay right away.
Is alfalfa safe for metabolic horses?
Alfalfa is often lower in NSC than grass hay, but it is higher in protein, calcium and calories. Some vets allow a little; many limit it for easy keepers. Ask your vet before feeding it.
What hay is best for an easy keeper?
Usually a tested grass hay that is lower in calories, not rich 2nd cut or alfalfa. Our Low Sugar 1st Cut Timothy-Orchard (lot 260910-01: 11.4% NSC, 8.9% protein, RFV 81, dry matter) is coarser and lower in energy, so easy keepers chew longer on fewer calories. Weigh the hay you feed and ask your vet how much your horse needs.
What hay should I feed a horse with EMS?
Many vets look for tested grass hay at about 10–12% NSC or less on a dry matter basis, fed by weight and often from a slow feeder. Our two tested lots are 11.4% and 10.3% NSC; neither is under 10%, so if your vet wants under 10%, ask whether soaking fits your horse. Hay does not treat EMS. Your vet sets the plan.
Is low starch hay the same as low sugar hay?
Not quite. NSC is sugar (WSC) plus starch. Grass hay is usually very low in starch. Both of our lots test 0.2% starch (dry matter), so in hay most of the NSC is sugar. Low starch alone does not make hay low sugar. Read the NSC or ESC + starch number on the test.
Do you sell hay under 10% NSC?
Not right now. Our two low sugar lots test at 11.4% and 10.3% NSC (DM). Both are under 10% on ESC + starch. If we list a lot under 10% NSC, it will show on our low sugar hay page with its test.
Can I get low sugar hay delivered in Connecticut, New Jersey, Massachusetts or New Hampshire?
Yes. We deliver tested low sugar hay free in all four states, one 18-bale pallet minimum, next-week delivery, set at ground level by forklift.
Sources
- Kentucky Equine Research: Horse Hay: Understanding Sugar and Starch Content
- ECIR Group: Treatment of EMS and Insulin Resistance
- Oregon State University Extension: Understanding Sugar and Nonstructural Carbohydrates in Equine Pasture and Hay
Test numbers are from Dairy One reports for lots 260910-01 (sampled Sept 11, 2026) and 261106-01 (sampled Nov 6, 2026). Lots sell out; current lots and full reports are always on each product page.
HayNow delivers here: Virginia to New Hampshire, including Washington, D.C.