Hay Testing Explained: How to Tell Good Hay
Share
Most hay buyers judge hay by color and smell. Those matter, but they can't tell you how much protein, sugar, or energy your animals are getting. A hay test can. This guide explains how to spot good hay by eye, what a hay analysis measures, and how to read the numbers that matter most.
How to Tell Good Hay by Looking
Before you ever see a lab report, your senses catch a lot.
- Smell: good hay smells sweet and fresh. Musty, moldy, sour, or burnt smells are red flags.
- Color: green inside the bale is a good sign. Outer layers may bleach in the sun, which mostly affects vitamins.
- Leaves: more leaves and fewer coarse stems usually mean better nutrition.
- Dust and mold: open a flake. If you see a dust cloud, white or gray patches, or matted clumps, don't feed it to horses.
- Foreign material: look for weeds, sticks, trash, and anything toxic. Blister beetles in alfalfa are a serious concern for horses.
- Feel: hay should be pliable, not brittle and not damp.
Why Test Hay?
Two bales that look the same can feed very differently. Extension specialists consistently point out that the cutting number and appearance can't predict nutrition reliably. Testing helps you:
- Match hay to your animals' needs instead of guessing.
- Spot high-sugar hay for insulin-resistant or laminitis-prone horses.
- Decide whether you need supplemental feed or grain at all.
- Avoid paying premium prices for average hay.
HayNow lab-tests every load of hay it sells. Want the test results for your hay? Email orders@haynow.com or call or text 315-599-2909, and our office will send what we have. We're working on making this automatic soon. We buy from growers across the United States and Canada, so testing is how we know what's in a lot before it goes on your pallet.
Reading a Hay Analysis: The Key Numbers
Dry Matter (DM) and Moisture
Hay is usually around 85 to 90% dry matter. Moisture well above 15 to 18% raises the risk of mold and heating. Reports often show values "as fed" and "dry matter basis." Compare hays on a dry matter basis.
Crude Protein (CP)
Protein supports muscle, growth, and milk. Adult horses at maintenance often do fine around 8 to 12%. Growing, working, and lactating animals need more. Alfalfa commonly tests 15 to 22%.
ADF (Acid Detergent Fiber)
ADF measures the least digestible fiber. Lower ADF means more digestible hay. Below about 35% is generally considered good-quality horse hay.
NDF (Neutral Detergent Fiber)
NDF is total fiber and predicts how much an animal will eat. Lower NDF means animals eat more. Grass hay often runs 55 to 65%. Alfalfa is lower.
NSC, ESC, and Starch (Sugars)
NSC (non-structural carbohydrates) is roughly sugar plus starch. For horses with insulin resistance, Cushing's (PPID), or a history of laminitis, many vets recommend hay under about 10 to 12% NSC. Always follow your vet's specific target.
For real numbers, see our guide to hay for metabolic horses. Our Low Sugar 1st Cut NY Timothy-Orchard Hay (lot 260910-01) tested 11.4% NSC and our Western Orchard Grass Hay, 2nd Cut (lot 261106-01) tested 10.3% NSC at Dairy One. Both fall in the roughly 12%-or-less range many vets use, but neither is under 10%, so ask your vet which target fits your horse.
Digestible Energy (DE)
DE estimates calories, usually in Mcal per pound or kilogram. Higher DE suits hard keepers and athletes. Lower DE suits easy keepers.
Minerals: Calcium and Phosphorus
Horses need more calcium than phosphorus, ideally a ratio of roughly 1.5 to 2 parts calcium to 1 part phosphorus. Alfalfa is very high in calcium. Grass hay is more balanced.
RFV and RFQ
Relative Feed Value and Relative Forage Quality are combined scores used mostly in the cattle and dairy world. Higher is better. For horses, the individual numbers above are more useful.
Quick Reference Table
| Measure | What it tells you | Generally better |
|---|---|---|
| Moisture | Storage safety | Under about 15% |
| Crude protein | Protein supply | Matched to the animal |
| ADF | Digestibility | Lower |
| NDF | Intake potential | Lower |
| NSC | Sugar and starch | Lower for metabolic horses |
| Ca:P | Mineral balance | About 1.5–2 : 1 for horses |
Matching Test Results to Your Hay Order
- Easy keepers: moderate protein 1st cut grass hay, like Timothy Orchard Grass, 1st Cut or Western Timothy, 1st Cut.
- Metabolic horses (insulin resistance, EMS, PPID or a laminitis history): hay with a posted sugar test, like Low Sugar 1st Cut Timothy-Orchard (11.4% NSC) or Western Orchard Grass, 2nd Cut (10.3% NSC). Ask your vet before changing hay.
- Hard keepers and performance horses: leafier grass like Western Orchard Grass, 2nd Cut, plus Western Steamed Alfalfa.
- Dairy goats and growing stock: higher protein hay or alfalfa.
Testing Your Own Hay
If you're buying from several sources, you can test it yourself. Use a hay probe to core 15 to 20 bales from the same lot, combine the samples in a sealed bag, and send them to a certified forage lab. Your county extension office can recommend one. Results usually come back within a week or two.
Questions to Ask Any Hay Seller
Whether you buy from a neighbor or online, a few questions protect your animals and your budget. Has this lot been tested, and can I see the results? What's the average bale weight? What species are in the bale, and roughly what mix? How was it stored before I get it? Has it been rained on? Is there any mold, dust, or weed problem I should know about? A good seller will answer plainly. If they can't tell you the bale weight or show you any testing, you're taking a gamble on what you're feeding. HayNow lab-tests every load, presses consistent ~43 lb bales, and ships them on shrink-wrapped 18-bale pallets, so you know what you're getting. When you've chosen your hay, order online and track your delivery automatically, from our Earlville, NY facility to your barn.
FAQ
Is green hay always better?
Not always. Green color suggests good curing, but it doesn't measure protein or sugar. Only a test does.
What does hay testing cost?
A basic forage analysis is usually inexpensive, often in the range of a few bales' worth of hay. Prices vary by lab and package.
What's a good protein level for horse hay?
About 8 to 12% suits most adult horses at maintenance. Higher-need horses may need more.
What NSC is safe for an insulin-resistant horse?
Many vets aim for under about 10 to 12% NSC, but follow your vet's guidance for your horse. Our two tested low sugar lots came in at 11.4% and 10.3% NSC; our metabolic horse hay guide compares them side by side.
Shop tested hay online with forklift delivery from New Hampshire to Virginia.