First Cut vs Second Cut Hay: What's the Difference?

Walk into any barn and ask whether first cut or second cut hay is better, and you'll get a strong opinion. The truth is less exciting and more useful. Cutting number tells you something about the hay, but not everything. Here's what the difference really is, which horses and animals each cut tends to suit, and how to choose.

What "Cutting" Means

Hay fields are harvested more than once a season. First cut is the first harvest, usually in late spring or early summer. Second cut comes from the regrowth several weeks later, and some regions get a third or fourth cutting. Each cutting grows under different weather and daylight conditions, so the hay looks and feeds differently.

First Cut Hay: The Basics

In cool-season grasses like timothy and orchard grass, the spring growth produces seed heads. Those grasses only head out once a year, so first cut tends to include more stems and seed heads.

  • Texture: coarser and stemmier
  • Fiber: usually higher
  • Protein and energy: usually lower
  • Weeds: early-season weeds can show up in first cut

Higher fiber and lower energy aren't flaws. For easy keepers, ponies, retired horses, and horses that need to chew longer without gaining weight, first cut grass hay is often an excellent choice. It keeps them busy and full.

Second Cut Hay: The Basics

The regrowth after first cutting is mostly leaves, with few or no seed heads. It often cures faster in summer heat, so it's less likely to be rained on.

  • Texture: softer, finer, leafier
  • Fiber: usually lower
  • Protein and energy: usually higher
  • Palatability: many horses prefer it

Second cut is popular for performance horses, hard keepers, seniors with dental wear, and picky eaters. It's also a favorite for goats, rabbits, and other small animals that like a fine, leafy hay.

The Myth: Second Cut Is Always Better

Extension specialists at the University of Kentucky and Michigan State are clear on this. The biggest factor in hay quality is plant maturity at harvest, not the cutting number. First cut cut early, before heading, can be excellent. Second cut cut late, or rained on, can be poor. Weather, curing, and storage matter as much as the calendar.

That's why a lab test beats a label. HayNow lab-tests every load it sells, so you're choosing based on what the hay is, not on a guess.

Which Cut Should You Choose?

Animal or situation Often a good fit
Easy keepers, ponies, retired horses 1st cut grass hay
Horses prone to weight gain or metabolic issues Hay with a posted sugar (NSC) test, fed in measured amounts (see our metabolic horse hay guide)
Performance or hard-keeping horses 2nd cut grass hay, sometimes with alfalfa
Seniors with worn teeth Soft 2nd cut
Goats, sheep, rabbits, small animals Leafy 2nd cut grass or alfalfa
Beef cattle on maintenance 1st cut grass hay

Many owners mix them, feeding first cut as the base and second cut as a top-up for horses that need more.

HayNow's First and Second Cut Options

HayNow buys hay from growers across the United States and Canada, then presses large bales into about 43 lb small bales at our Earlville, NY facility. Every pallet holds 18 bales and is shrink-wrapped for protection on the road.

How to Tell Cuts Apart by Looking

  • Seed heads: plenty of them points to first cut grass.
  • Stem thickness: thick, stiff stems are typical of first cut.
  • Leafiness: fine, dense leaves are typical of second cut.
  • Color: both should be green to light green inside the bale. Color alone doesn't tell you the cut.

Switching Between Cuts

Any hay change should be gradual. Mix the new hay in over 7 to 10 days so your animals' digestion can adjust. That's especially important when moving to richer second cut or adding alfalfa.

Buying First or Second Cut in Winter

Supplies of soft second cut often get tight by late winter, because demand is high and there's simply less of it harvested per acre. If you know your horses need second cut, order early in the season or set up regular deliveries so you're not stuck with whatever is left in March. First cut tends to be more widely available year-round. Because HayNow buys hay from growers across the United States and Canada, rather than depending on a single local field, we can usually keep both cuttings in stock longer than a typical local supplier. Ordering online lets you check what's available, pick your cut, and get next-week delivery with automated tracking. If a local barn runs out, you're not left choosing between the wrong hay and no hay. Planning a winter's worth? Start with a mix of both cuttings so you have flexibility as your horses' condition changes through the cold months.

FAQ

Is first or second cut hay better for horses?

Neither is always better. First cut suits easy keepers and horses that need more fiber. Second cut suits horses that need more energy or a softer hay. A hay test is the best guide.

Is second cut hay higher in sugar?

Not necessarily. Sugar (NSC) depends on species, weather, and time of cutting. Test the hay if your horse is insulin resistant. Our own lab results show it: our 2nd cut Western Orchard Grass (lot 261106-01) tested 10.3% NSC, a little lower than our 1st cut Low Sugar Timothy-Orchard (lot 260910-01) at 11.4% (Dairy One). See hay for metabolic horses and ask your vet.

Why does second cut cost more?

There's usually less of it per acre, and demand for soft, leafy hay is high.

Is first cut good for goats?

Goats can eat it, but many prefer the leafier second cut or alfalfa, especially does in milk.

Not sure which to order? Browse our hay or check delivery in your state.

Back to blog