Timothy vs Orchard Grass vs Alfalfa Hay: How to Choose
Share
Timothy, orchard grass, and alfalfa are the three hays horse and livestock owners in the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic ask about most. They're all good feeds, but they aren't interchangeable. This guide compares nutrition, texture, and which animals each one suits, so you can order the right hay the first time.
The Big Difference: Grass vs Legume
Timothy and orchard grass are grasses. Alfalfa is a legume, in the same plant family as clover and peas. That's the main thing to know.
- Grass hays are higher in fiber and moderate in protein and calcium. They're the everyday base forage for most horses.
- Legume hays like alfalfa are higher in protein, energy, and calcium. They're a richer feed, often used as a supplement.
Actual values vary with maturity at harvest, weather, and the field. Treat the ranges below as typical, and rely on a hay test for specifics.
Timothy Hay
Timothy is a cool-season grass and the classic horse hay. It's known for consistent quality and moderate nutrition.
- Typical crude protein: about 7 to 11%
- Texture: long stems with seed heads in first cut, finer in later cuttings
- Best for: adult horses at maintenance, easy keepers, rabbits and guinea pigs, and any animal that needs plenty of fiber
Shop: Western Timothy Hay, 1st Cut Ultra Premium or the softer Western Timothy Hay, 2nd Cut.
Orchard Grass Hay
Orchard grass is another cool-season grass. It's usually leafier and softer than timothy and tends to regrow well, so later cuttings are common.
- Typical crude protein: about 8 to 14%
- Texture: soft and leafy with a sweet smell, which many horses love
- Best for: picky eaters, seniors, horses needing a bit more energy than timothy, and small animals
Shop: Western Straight Orchard Grass Hay, 2nd Cut.
Timothy and Orchard Grass Mixes
Many Northeast fields are seeded with both grasses, giving a balanced hay with timothy's structure and orchard grass's leafiness. It's one of the most popular all-around horse hays we sell.
Shop: Timothy Orchard Grass Hay, 1st Cut and NY Timothy Orchard Grass Hay, 2nd Cut.
Alfalfa Hay
Alfalfa is the energy and protein heavyweight.
- Typical crude protein: about 15 to 22%
- Calcium: high, which can help buffer stomach acid in some horses
- Best for: hard keepers, performance horses, growing horses, broodmares, dairy goats, and other livestock with high nutrient needs
- Use with care for: easy keepers, overweight horses, and animals whose diet needs controlled calcium. Male goats and sheep are at risk of urinary stones with too much calcium relative to phosphorus, so ask your vet.
Many owners feed alfalfa as a portion of the ration, such as a flake alongside grass hay, rather than as the only forage.
Shop: Western Steamed Alfalfa Hay.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Timothy | Orchard grass | Alfalfa | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Type | Grass | Grass | Legume |
| Protein | Lower | Moderate | High |
| Energy | Lower | Moderate | High |
| Calcium | Moderate | Moderate | High |
| Texture | Stemmy to medium | Soft, leafy | Leafy, can be brittle |
| Typical role | Base forage | Base forage | Supplement or high-need animals |
Which Hay for Which Animal?
Horses
Most adult horses do best with timothy, orchard grass, or a mix as their main forage. Add alfalfa for horses that need more condition or work hard.
Cattle
Beef cattle at maintenance usually do fine on grass hay. Growing calves and lactating cows benefit from higher-protein hay or some alfalfa.
Goats and Sheep
Goats are browsers and like leafy hay. Does in milk do well with alfalfa in the mix. Wethers and rams usually do better on mostly grass hay.
Rabbits, Guinea Pigs, and Small Animals
Adult small animals generally need grass hay like timothy or orchard grass. Alfalfa is usually reserved for young or nursing animals.
Bedding
For stalls, coops, and kidding pens, straw beats hay. Try our bright, clean wheat straw.
Why Testing Matters More Than the Name
Two bales of timothy can feed very differently depending on when they were cut and how they were cured. HayNow buys hay from growers across the US and Canada and lab-tests every load, so you can match hay to your animals instead of guessing. We press it into about 43 lb small bales at our Earlville, NY facility, palletize 18 bales per pallet, shrink-wrap it, and deliver with on-board forklifts.
Buying Tips for Each Hay Type
When you're comparing hay from different sellers, ask the same questions regardless of type. Was it tested, and can you see the results? (At HayNow, email orders@haynow.com or call or text 315-599-2909 for results.) What's the bale weight? A cheaper bale that weighs 30 lb isn't a bargain next to a 43 lb bale. How was it stored before delivery? For timothy, look for fine stems and green color without excessive seed heads. For orchard grass, expect a softer, leafier bale, and watch that it isn't dusty, since leafy hay can shatter if it's handled roughly. For alfalfa, check that leaves are still attached, because most of alfalfa's nutrition is in the leaves, and inspect for blister beetles. Steamed alfalfa has been heat-treated to reduce dust, which some owners prefer for horses with breathing issues. Finally, plan your switch. Whenever you change hay type, blend old and new over 7 to 10 days to protect digestion.
FAQ
Is timothy or orchard grass better for horses?
Both are excellent. Timothy is a bit higher in fiber. Orchard grass is usually softer and more palatable. Many owners choose a mix.
Can horses eat only alfalfa?
Some can, but most horses are better off with grass hay as the base and alfalfa as a supplement, because alfalfa alone can supply more energy and calcium than needed.
Is alfalfa good for goats?
It's great for does in milk and growing kids. Bucks and wethers generally need mostly grass hay.
What hay is best for cattle?
Grass hay covers most beef cattle at maintenance. Add higher-protein hay for growing and lactating animals.
Find your hay in our online shop, with next-week delivery from New Hampshire to Virginia.